E-scooters had been supposed to repair journey in Rome. Then they turned a significant downside


Rome (CNN) — Rome, the everlasting metropolis, has been invaded, conquered and pillaged numerous instances since its founding practically 2,800 years in the past. Every assault has left scars all through the town, from the ruins of the Roman Discussion board to the cavern of the Circus Maximus the place chariots as soon as raced.

Trendy degradation has additionally left residents indignant, fed up with what usually seems like complacency in what’s arguably probably the most lovely cities on this planet.

The present invasion of the Italian capital comes from e-scooters — greater than 14,000 of them — fashionable chariots that block sidewalks, unnerve drivers and kill.

Since rental scooters had been launched three years in the past as a substitute for public transportation through the Covid pandemic, 4 individuals have been killed whereas driving them, based on Rome Metropolis Corridor mobility councilman Eugenio Patane. Town’s emergency rooms deal with at the very least one scooter-related main harm each three days, well being authorities say.

And but solely 2% (round 270) of the foot scooters for lease are used each day.

Rome Metropolis Corridor has given licenses to seven corporations chargeable for altering batteries, finishing up repairs, transferring scooters to high-traffic areas and fishing them out of the town’s Tiber River.

It is the scooters that are not in use which can be presenting the best problem, particularly to the disabled.

‘A collection of frights’

Officials say only 2% of 14,000 rental scooters in Rome are in use.

Officers say solely 2% of 14,000 rental scooters in Rome are in use.

Lorenzo Di Cola/NurPhoto/Getty Pictures

As Giuliano Frittelli, head of the Italian Union for the Blind and Visually Impaired, navigates along with his strolling stick round a half a dozen scooters littering the sidewalk close to his workplace within the metropolis heart, he tells CNN that for individuals who do not see, they’re a loss of life lure.

“The primary downside is the wild parking,” Frittelli says as he faucets his strolling stick on the bottom of a scooter, explaining that their uncommon form additionally makes it straightforward for somebody with impaired eyesight to journey over them.

He additionally says that as a result of they’re electrical, they’re silent, which can be a menace to those that can not see.

“You do not hear them so you can not navigate round them,” Frittelli says, recalling an incident when a scooter handed a blind particular person so carefully their startled seeing-eye canine jumped off the sidewalk, inflicting what he referred to as “a collection of frights” that fortunately didn’t finish in bodily harm.

Frittelli’s group is working with Rome Metropolis Corridor to make it necessary that scooters are parked solely in designated stalls. He additionally desires them tailored to provide a noise degree of at the very least 30 decibels so it may function a warning of their method.

He says it isn’t simply disabled individuals, together with these in wheelchairs, who battle to make use of the streets when the sidewalks are strewn with scooters. The aged and oldsters pushing child strollers are additionally affected.

Giuliano Frittelli

Giuliano Frittelli, left, desires it to be necessary for scooters to be parked in designated locations.


Rome Metropolis Corridor site visitors councilman Eugenio Patanè agrees. He tells CNN that as of January 1, 2023, the town will renew the permission for simply 9,000 scooters and scale back the variety of corporations allowed to lease them to 3.

He says that the town additionally plans to require a share of the scooters to be positioned within the suburbs and different areas so common residents can use them for what he refers to as “the final mile” which may take them from a subway cease to their properties or enable them to run fast errands with out leaping in a automobile.

“They’re a hazard to the individuals, however they’re additionally an issue for the town, for the fantastic thing about the town,” Patanè says. “The middle of the town is a UNESCO heritage web site and could be very fragile and we have now to deal with it.”

Assosharing, Italy’s shared mobility commerce affiliation, stated in a press release that accidents involving e-scooters had been uncommon — 44 for each 10,000 scooters — with severe incidents largely confined to privately owned tools.

“The alarmist tones are, in essence, disconnected from actuality,” the assertion stated. “Initially, it must be made clear that the usage of automobiles in Rome is in step with different European capitals.”

The group stated that Rome’s experiences had been on a par with different main European cities, though Italy was lagging behind in implementing laws that might assist guarantee e-scooters can turn into a key a part of transport options.

“Assosharing emphasizes the necessity to enhance the variety of parking areas devoted to scooters in Rome and to activate new cycle lanes, in step with the primary European capitals’ requirements,” it stated.

Ignoring the principles

A tourist recently threw a scooter down the Spanish Steps.

A vacationer just lately threw a scooter down the Spanish Steps.

Polizia Roma Capitale

In early June, two Individuals had been fined round $800 for throwing rental scooters down the Spanish Steps, inflicting about $26,000 value of injury to the delicate marble. The incident was caught on safety cameras and by passersby who noticed one of many vacationers throw the heavy steel scooter, capturing the sound of it crashing into the steps.

The e-scooters are primarily utilized by vacationers and younger individuals, Patanè says.

And the principles are sometimes ignored, particularly people who prohibit use on sidewalks and restrict riders to 1 particular person. Renters are additionally speculated to be 18 years previous. And the town can not oblige the rental corporations to supply helmets, which means only a few individuals put on them.

Police checks are rare and fines are uncommon for scooter customers breaking the fundamental guidelines since it’s tough to implement the no-sidewalk rule when the scooters are usually parked on the sidewalks.

They seem like successful with vacationers although. “To trip round, particularly the historic heart the place it is virtually inconceivable in a automobile, that is it,” Walter Hughes, from Dallas, Texas instructed CNN.

“For that [two- or three-mile radius] that you just trip quick round, you can not discover a parking spot for a automobile, it is too sizzling to stroll for 5 hours, so that is it.”

Not everybody agrees.

Taxi drivers who’ve needed to weave via pedestrians and mopeds for years say the e-scooters are a far greater downside.

Eduardo Conticello has had many near-misses along with his taxi and want to see scooters abolished utterly.

He tells CNN that they usually cease quick in entrance of him or fall over. “Once I see them I drive very, very slowly,” he explains, which provides time to his journeys, which means his passengers pay extra due to them. “They’re very harmful.”

However life within the everlasting metropolis has by no means been significantly straightforward in its 2,800 years. Rome wasn’t in-built a day, as they are saying. And its issues will not be solved in a single both.

This story has been up to date with a press release from Italian shared mobility affiliation Assosharing


Supply hyperlink